Home / Business With Us / Regulatory & Permitting / Appealed Decisions

Administrative Appeals

The North Atlantic Division performs the administrative appeal process for permitting decisions and jurisdictional determinations within the New England District, New York District, Philadelphia District, Baltimore District and Norfolk District. North Atlantic Division also assists on appeals nationally when requested by other Division Commanders. The appeals received by the North Atlantic Division Headquarters are shown below.

For general information regarding the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Administrative Appeals process, you may contact: Andrew Dangler, Administrative Appeal Review Officer, North Atlantic Division via email at andrew.c.dangler@usace.army.mil or via telephone at (518) 487-0215.

Appeals Received

Applicant's
Name
District
Application
No.
Appealable
Action
Date
Received
Date Accepted
or Rejected (A/R)
Final Appeal
Decision Date
Final Appeal
Decision
Ocean Road Development Corp.
NAE 
 199802590 Permit Denial
20 Nov 1999
17 Dec 1999 (R)
N/A
 Not Accepted
Maine Moorings, LLC

NAE

199901942 Permit Denial
25 Aug 2000
20 Nov 2000 (A)
30 Apr 2001
 Has Merit
City of Virginia Beach 99-0272-09 Permit Denial
30 Aug 2000
18 Sep 2000 (A)
Withdrawn
by applicant
 N/A
Frank Attanasio
NAP 
 199900072-46 Permit Denial
10 Oct 2000
8 Nov 2001 (A)
29 Apr 2002
 Has Merit 
Holton-Arms School
NAB 
 200067338 Jurisdictional
Determination
17 Jan 2001
24 Jan 2001 (R)
N/A
 Not Accepted
John P. Kupfer
00-R-2533 Jurisdictional
Determination
29 Mar 2001
11 Apr 2001 (A)
25 Jan 2002
 Has Merit
Allen Gordon
01-R-0173 Jurisdictional
Determination
10 Apr 2001
17 May 2001 (A)
25 Jan 2002
 No Merit
Delaware Dept. of Transportation
NAP 
 200001805-11 Jurisdictional
Determination
20 Jun 2001
24 Sep 2001 (R)
N/A
 Not Accepted
Henry Zapruder 00-66704-1 Permit Denial
13 Feb 2002
19 Apr 2002 (A)
31 Jul 2002
 Has Merit
Prince George's County DER 01-64083-15 Jurisdictional
Determination
15 Feb 2002
21 Feb 2002 (R)
N/A
 Not Accepted
Deale-Churchton Road Partnership
NAB 
 01-61506-3 Jurisdictional
Determination
1 Apr 2002
11 Apr 2002 (A)
2 Jul 2002
 No Merit
Intercoastal Industrial Park L.P.
NAB 
 00-66420-15 Jurisdictional
Determination
21 May 2002
31 May 2002 (A)
31 Jul 2002
 No Merit
Daniel M. Meehan
NAN 
 2002-00023-YN Jurisdictional
Determination
25 Sept 2002
16 Oct 2002 (A)
19 Nov 2002
 Has Merit
E. Tetz & Sons, Inc.
& Concrete Properties 		2000-00117-YS Jurisdictional
Determination
24 Dec 2002
3 Jan 2003 (A)
24 June 2003
 No Merit
Joseph Shay
NAE 
 200201665 Jurisdictional
Determination
11 Feb 2003
24 March 2003 (R)
N/A
 Not Accepted
134 Water Street Trust
NAE 
 200202624 Jurisdictional
Determination
28 Feb 2003
4 April 2003 (R)
N/A
 Not Accepted
Francis C. Warrington
NAP 
 200201775-26 Jurisdictional
Determination
4 Apr 2003
22 May 2003 (A)
25 July 2003
 Has Merit
Taylor Bros. Builders, Inc.
96-R5759 Jurisdictional
Determination
31 July 2003
1 Oct 2003 (R)
N/A
 Not Accepted
James Craig, Jr.
03-N230 Jurisdictional
Determination
25 Aug 2003
16 Sept 2003 (A)
Withdrawn by
applicant
 N/A
David Fusco
NAN 
 2000-01007-YN Jurisdictional
Determination
17 Sep 2003
30 Sep 2003 (A)
5 Dec 2003
 Has Merit
Caldera Properties, LP
NAP 
 200201383-23 Jurisdictional
Determination

22 Oct 2003
7 Nov 2003 (A)
5 Mar 2004
 No Merit
Caldera Properties, LP
NAP 
 200201999-26 Jurisdictional
Determination

22 Oct 2003
7 Nov 2003 (A)
5 Mar 2004
 No Merit
Irvine Nature Center
NAB 
 02-63179-4 Jurisdictional
Determination

31 Oct 2003
7 Nov 2003 (A)
5 Mar 2004
 Has Merit
Orleans Homebuilders, Inc.
NAP 
 200001011-46 Jurisdictional
Determination
15 Dec 2003
16 Jan 2004 (R)
N/A
 Not Accepted
Commonwealth of PA DOT 199800918 Proffered Permit
13 May 2004
8 June 2004 (A)
4 October 2004
 Has Merit
Frank J. Guarini
NAN 
 2004-00304-J2 Jurisdictional
Determination
9 June 2004
12 July 2004 (A)
24 Sep 2004
 No Merit
J.B. Jennings
04-R1415 Jurisdictional
Determination
12 July 2004
26 July 2004 (A)
8 Dec 2004
 Has Merit
Rouse Chamberlin Homes
NAP 
 200400227-60 Jurisdictional
Determination
30 July 2004
24 Aug 2004 (A)
Withdrawn by
applicant
 N/A
Port Jervis School District
NAN 
 2003-01187-YS Jurisdictional
Determination
8 Sep 2004
21 Sep 2004 (A)
10 Nov 2004
 Has Merit
Rudy A. Ciccotti
NAN 
 2004-00551-YM Jurisdictional
Determination
20 Sep 2004
29 Oct 2004 (R)
N/A
 Not Accepted
Rohm & Haas Company
NAP 
 200200634-24 Jurisdictional
Determination
4 Oct 2004
6 Oct 2004 (A)
Withdrawn by appellant
 N/A
Dean Yaxa  2004-00051-L2 Proffered Permit   
5 Oct 2004
6 Oct 2004 (R)
N/A
 Not Accepted
William & Agnes E. Mohr
NAN 
 2003-00236-YN Jurisdictional
Determination
22 Oct 2004
8 Nov 2004 (A)
10 March 2005
 No Merit
Kenneth Woodring 2004-00460-26 Jurisdictional
Determination
17 Nov 2004
13 Dec 2004 (R)
Withdrawn by
applicant
 N/A
John C. Steinberg, Jr.
NAN 
 2003-00407-YS Jurisdictional
Determination
24 Mar 2005
5 Apr 2005 (A)
Withdrawn by
applicant
 N/A
Friendship Estates, LLC 200200467-56 Jurisdictional
Determination
5 Apr 2005
N/A
N/A
 Not Accepted
Lee Brook Associates, LLC
NAE 
 2004-1852 Jurisdictional
Determination
12 Apr 2005
26 Apr 2005 (R)
N/A
 Not Accepted
Wayne Cameron 2005-01986-18 Jurisdictional
Determination
31 May 05
6 Jun 05 (A)
4 Oct 2005
 No Merit
Nicholas Peles
NAP 
 2005-00414-30 Jurisdictional
Determination
23 June 2005
29 June 2005 (A)
27 Dec 2005
 No Merit
John Grier Construction Company
02-V1749 Permit Denial
2 Sept 2005
17 Nov 2005 (A)
7 Mar 2006
 No Merit
Robert Suppe 200500527-60 Jurisdictional
Determination
6 Dec 2005
7 Dec 2005 (A)
23 Feb 2006
 No Merit
G & D Integrated
05-R2919 Jurisdictional Determination
9 Dec 2005
3 Jan 2006 (R)
N/A
 Not Accepted
Legacy Development
05-R3049 Jurisdictional Determination
19 Dec 2005
9 Jan 2006 (A)
27 Apr 2006
 Has Merit
Lee T. McIntosh
05-R1164 Jurisdictional Determination
23 Dec 2005
15 Feb 2006 (R) 
N/A
 Not Accepted
Pulte Homes of PA, LP 200500708-60 Jurisdictional Determination
30 Dec 2005
11 Jan 2006 (A)
7 Mar 2006
 Has Merit
Merrimart Management Company LLC
NAB 
 200600709 Jurisdictional Determination
9 Mar 2006
26 Jun 2006
2 Aug 2007
 Has Merit
EWN Development
05-G0084 Jurisdictional Determination
10 Mar 2006
13 Mar 2006 (R)
N/A
 Not Accepted
Green Lane Properties, LLC 200600428-35 Jurisdictional Determination
12 Apr 2007
16 Apr 2007 (A)
Withdrawn by appellant
 N/A
Precon Development Corp.
NAO-2007-240 Jurisdictional Determination
23 Jul 2007
17 Aug 2007 (A)
10 Dec 2007
 Has Merit
Thomas Byrd, Jr. 199802562-46 Permit Denial
13 Aug 2007
16 Nov 2007 (A)
2 May 2008
 No Merit
Precon Development Corp.
NAO-2007-240 Permit Denial
10 Sept 2007
2 Oct 2007 (A)
17 July 2008
 No Merit
Town of Warrenton
06-V0553 Permit Denial
15 Feb 2008
22 Feb 2008 (A)
23 July 2008
 No Merit
Tri-City Properties, LLC
NAO-2006-06097 Permit Denial
1 May 2008
29 May 2008 (A)
29 May 08
 No Merit
Mori Properties, Inc. NAN-2008-318-WCA Jurisdictional Determination
9 May 2008
9 Jun 2008 (A)
1 Dec 2008
 No Merit
Dodson Farm, LLC
NAO-2007-3583 Jurisdictional Determination
14 May 2008
6 Jun 2008 (A)
22 Dec 2008
 Has Merit
Cardinal Properties, LLC
NAO-2008-0746 Jurisdictional Determination
5 Jun 2008
12 Jun 2008 (A)
3 Oct 2008
 No Merit
Passion Tilghman. NAB-2009-533-M13 Jurisdictional Determination
28 Mar 2009
30 July 2009 (R)
N/A
 Not Accepted
Pizzagalli Properties, LLC. NAE-2009-1770 Jurisdictional Determination
6 Oct 2009
18 Dec 2009 (R)
N/A
 Not Accepted
Lawrence Whitlock
NAO-2009-01402 Jurisdictional Determination
1 Feb 2010
24 Feb 2010 (A)
11 Feb 2011
 Has Merit
E. O. Drumheller
NAO-2009-1175 Jurisdictional Determination
6 Apr 2010
3 Jun 2010 (R)
N/A
 N/A
Bill Himchak NAB-RPA-2010-02125-P06 Jurisdictional Determination
5 Oct 2010
17 Dec 2010 (R)
N/A
 N/A
J. Blair Mitchell
NAO-2010-02246 Jurisdictional Determination
10 Aug 2011
25 Aug 2011
N/A
 No Merit
46 Mill Plain, LLC
NAE 
 NAE-2005-1505 Jurisdictional Determination
26 Aug 2011
19 Sep 2011 (A)
23 March 2012
 Has Merit
Virginia Tech Corporate Research Center
NAO-2007-1371 Jurisdictional Determination
16 Sep 2011
19 Sep 2011 (A)
15 Dec 2011

Has Merit
Raymond and Mildred Roberts
NAP 
 NAP-2012-0364   Jurisdictional Determination 4 Oct 2012 7 Oct 2012 (A) 6 Feb 2013 No Merit
Borough of Carteret NAN NAN-2012-01198 Denied Permit 3 May 2013 21 May 2013 (A) 5 Dec 2013 Has Merit
Ernest and Lauren Park NAE NAE-2008-2668 Jurisdictional Determination 11 Mar 2013 29 April 2013 (A) 5 Dec 2013 Has Merit
Scott Camp NAO NAO-2009-01852 Jurisdictional Determination 23 Sep 2013 10 Oct 2013 (A)  17 Sep 2014 Has Merit
Steven Smith NAP NAP-2013-0293   Jurisdictional Determination  2 Jun 2014 18 Jul 2014 (A) 11 Mar 2015  No Merit 
Joseph Rollins NAO NAO-2014-00936   Jurisdictional Determination  13 Apr 2015 12 May 2015 (A) 9 Jan 2016  No Merit 
William & Florence Fleidner NAP NAP-2012-00517   Jurisdictional Determination  4 Dec 2015 2 Mar 2016 (R) N/A  N/A 
Pungo Air Field, LLC NAO NAO-2016-10839   Jurisdictional Determination 4 Apr 2017  1 May 2017 (A)  27 Jun 2017  No Merit
Beverly Hodges NAO NAO-2017-00914 Jurisdictional Determination 27 Feb 2018   17 Apr 2018 (R)  N/A Not
Accepted 
Diamond Group Properties, LLC NAO NAO-2019-00962 Jurisdictional Determination 5 Sep 2019   11 Oct 2019 (A)  N/A Withdrawn 
 James & Irene Minter NAO NAO-2017-00737 Jurisdictional Determination 6 Sep 2019  4 Oct 2019 (A) 15 Oct 2020 Has Merit